Two protective genetic conditions against malaria are fatal together

By Henry Neondo, Yaounde, Cameroon

A new study of Kenyan children that was discussed Tuesday at the ongoing Fourth Multilateral Initiative on Malaria Pan-African Malaria Conference in Yaoundé, Cameroon show that two genetic conditions—sickle cell trait and a mild version of the blood disorder known as thalassemia—that by themselves give millions of Africans natural protection against malaria, can be rendered essentially useless when they occur together.

“We’ve looked at these traits individually and we expected that if people had both of them, they would be really protected,” said Tom Williams, a Wellcome Senior Research Fellow at the Kenya Medical Research Institute (KEMRI) and the study’s lead author.

“But it turns out that when you start combining the two, you can lose the effect of both.”

With malaria researchers eager to find and understand more about genetic traits that confer protection against malaria, the study—recently published in Nature Genetics—shows how challenging it can be to pinpoint protective genes and, moreover, predict how they might be influenced by other traits.

“This is an important finding in part because a huge effort is being poured into malaria genomics and the search for genetic associations with malaria,” Williams said.

“Our study shows that it can be very complicated to turn up genetic associations and properly understand them. If one trait can interfere with the effects of another, you may miss an association where one truly exists. Conversely, you may find a trait that seems to provide protection but not see how other traits could alter the effect.”

Nonetheless, Williams said the finding—which involved chronicling the genetic and malarial status of more than 2,000 children, most starting at birth—can help scientists learn more about discrete, if complex, biological mechanisms at work in naturally acquired immunity.

For several years Williams’ research has probed how certain genetic factors provide Africans with a degree of natural protection against malaria. A key focus of his work has been the underlying effects of the sickle cell trait, which became relatively common in humans as an evolutionary, protective genetic response to thousands of years of exposure to malaria.

Individuals with sickle cell trait inherit one normal hemoglobin gene from one parent and a sickle hemoglobin gene from another.

Studies have shown that when children with the sickle trait are exposed to malaria, they suffer far fewer parasites and are 90 per cent less likely to be hospitalized by a malaria infection than those without the trait. The protective effect increases with age.

Meanwhile, Williams said researchers have long known that a genetic variation known as alpha thalassemia—which is common in sub-Saharan Africa but, unlike beta thalassemia, is not associated with major health problems—also helps people fight malaria.

While not offering as much protection as the sickle trait, Williams said children with the thalassemia trait are less likely to die from a malaria infection because it prevents severe anemia, which can complicate other malaria-induced conditions.

The degree to which the interaction between the traits dilutes their protective effect depends on the type of alpha thalassemia gene involved. (There are two sub-varieties.) But Williams said when the sickle trait exists alongside the type found routinely in malaria endemic regions of Africa, “all the good work of these genes is lost and you end up with the same degree of risk as someone who has neither trait.”

Williams said the finding does not affect treatment decisions but is valuable to researchers as a stark example of the genetic interactions that can occur in malaria.

He said the research also demonstrates why certain critical issues related to malaria cannot be resolved unless there are scientists equipped with modern technology working directly with people in the areas of Africa most affected by malaria.

For example, Williams said, his insights would not have been possible if he had not been working directly with Africans who are routinely exposed to malaria and employing a relatively new technology that allows scientists to quickly screen the genetic profile of a large number of people.

“This is another example of the incredible new insights that emerge from supporting malaria research in Africa,” said Andreas Heddini, the MIM Secretariat coordinator. “There are many scientists interested in malaria genetics. But as this study shows, findings that come only from the laboratory will be limited unless they are supported by strong evidence from population studies in Africa.”

Interest in fighting malaria by studying particular genetic factors related to the disease has increased over the past few years following the sequencing of the genomes of the most deadly form of malaria and its mosquito carrier.